If you are the type to work on it could improve it with some work and get that paint off. I always leave as is and displays fine as it is. In pretty nice shape for age.
All of these trays are tough to find but I was told the first and second tray are the toughest of the six. Stamped H D Beach Co coshocton o.The item "Lemp Beer Tray Charger 1908 2nd Tray Falstaff Pre Pro Old Sign Antique 24 In" is in sale since Tuesday, January 15, 2019. This item is in the category "Collectibles\Breweriana, Beer\Pre-Prohibition". The seller is "jata" and is located in Janesville, Wisconsin.
This item can be shipped to United States.